Is war ever justified

Pro I'd like to thank my opponent for beginning this interesting debate. While I agree that war is horrific and should be avoided at all costs, I acknowledge that in some rare circumstances war might be appropriate. To help demonstrate my case, I'll be utilizing the Just War Theory - a doctrine of military ethics of Roman philosophical and Catholic origin [1]. Essentially it sets up a framework of criteria that must be met in order for a war to be justified.

Is war ever justified

Is war ever justified

Student Answers franzvillan Student is the end all and be all, we have to realize that the potential to break this cycle is what truly makes us human and we have the ability and the compassion to break this killer instinct.

Every war has an ulterior motive I'm sure you people don't need examples and every time war is advertised it's referred to as service to your country but are you really fightng for the common man?

Naive soldiers and media poisoned teenagers always say there is a greater good soldiers are fighting for, but the soldier I met disagrees, he said he joined the military because he had no choice, that it was the only way he could afford an educaton and to support his family.

Humanity has to wake up, we have to stop lamenting about the present, stop telling ourselves that what humanity is now. They force their cynical views about war and humanity upon them, they tell the that it's naive t wish for peace,that it's naive to work towards mutual understanding, in the end they corrupted an idealistic mind into another Is war ever justified cynic, who's only goal in life is to keep spoiling themselves til death, they corrupted hope for the future into into a bitter acceptance of the present, ignoring the fight for change,ignoring the ideals that humanity should follow, in favor of following the easy path, the path of apathy, the path of greed but most of all the path of conflict.

National ideologies do nothing for humanity, it's lead us into this bloody state of neo-feudalism where the most trivial of things can escalate into war and the cruel way society treats idealists is proof of the majority of cynics, they are portrayed in the media as Hippies and paranoid anarchists, franzvillan Student Is War Ever Justified?

It seems to me that more and more people in our society believe that war is never justified. I think this is a naive view. Slavery in the United States was wrong, and it is too bad that our country had to suffer terribly from the Civil War, but if that is what it took to end slavery, that is what it took.

Adolf Hitler was evil. He killed millions of people for nothing but their race. Neville Chamberlain tried negotiation with him, but Hitler broke the pact as soon as it was convenient. Evil people do not keep their promises.

They say one thing and do another. How can we negotiate or compromise with someone who does not keep their word. There are still some things worth dying for and things like the freedom to worship as we choose, the right to a fair trial before imprisonment, the right of people to live in safety without constant fear, the right of women to be treated as humans not animals.

These are things worth fighting and even dying for. No war is ever justified.

Debate: Is War Ever Justified?

My old college professor was a soldier and he didn't see any glory or sense of nationalism in war. He saw it for what it was,Bloodshed, he told me that when you take a life you didn't kill an enemy of your country, you killed someone's father,brother,husband or child. The truly naive message is the one that says war will forever be in human nature,Humans are different we have the ability to rationalize, which is Ironically the same trait in us that causes us to justify genocide and to twist the image of war into this patriotic crusade that people want to believe in but it is that same rationality that drives us into innovation, the same rationality that that tels us that war is pointless.

Human evolution is far from finished, and it is very naive to think humans will always be like this. People are obsessed with the here and now, what they can see, what they perceive as real but that isn't productive. People can't see a future.

That is absurd and is the sort of idea propagated by our media networks. The "terrorists" didn't attack the World Trade Centers to destroy freedom. They are humans just like us. They have reasons for their actions and simple human desires like us Now of course their action was an act of war, and was negative and involved taking innocent lives.

And all it did was make us want to fight back. We could have saved a lot more lives by staying out of their country. After all, "terrorism", as defined by the department of Homeland Security, only claims around 97 lives a year.

And thus, positive action trumps negative in resolving the issue. Also, terrorism is the use of fear to help acheieve swaying a set of ideals or agendas in motion. Is that not what our government has done to us in the past decade or really since WWII?Hence, in my opinion, war is never justified.

Back in the s A.D, Muslims were engaged in a series of war against the Quraish. These wars can simply be titled as the most systematic wars in. In this debate, Jan Ting, professor of law at Temple University, and Bryan Caplan, professor of economics at George Mason University, discuss whether war is ever justified.

Prof. Ting argues that while war should be a last resort, there are occasions where the consequences of . To see why, consider the six criteria just war theorists, including Biggar, use to determine when a war is morally justified. The war must be undertaken with the intention of establishing a just.

Can war ever be justified? The example of Jesus is central to Christians’ attitude to war. He was presented with an opportunity to lead an armed uprising, but he refused. God’s view of war has not changed—he uses it as a legitimate means to end oppression and wickedness. However, God’s war of Armageddon will end all wars.

Debate: Can war ever be justified? | Ting argues that while war should be a last resort, there are occasions where the consequences of not going to war outweigh the costs of war. He uses World War II as an example in which war prevented great evil.
Debate: Can war ever be justified? | As we reel in the aftermath of the Syrian situation, most focus on which team scored or gave up the most points, Team Putin, Team Obama, Team Republican, Team Democrat. But, as we direct our gaze to the scoreboard and squint through cloudy punditary prisms to try and make out the numbers, we miss a greater opportunity.
Is War Ever Justified Submit All wars are justifiable, few are justified.
Related Questions Go back Can war ever be justified? He was presented with an opportunity to lead an armed uprising, but he refused.

The words of Jesus are unambiguous: "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." [Matt. ] These familiar words from the Sermon on the Mount form the basis of any Christian understanding of war and its morality. For the Christian, the standard is already set and the goal is absolutely clear--we are to seek the peace.

Can war ever be justified? - Christianity UK