The role of evidence in the criminal justice system

There were 2, black male prisoners with sentences over one year perblack male residents in the United States, and a total ofblack male sentenced prisoners in the United States as of December 31,

The role of evidence in the criminal justice system

Forms Introduction [1] For at least 15 years, experienced and respected members of the judiciary have raised concerns about the increasing length of criminal trials. Unless, we, as courts, can find some method of rescuing our criminal trial process from the almost Dickensian procedural morass that it is now bogged down in, the public will lose patience with our traditional adversarial system of justice.

As Jonathan Swift might have said, we are presently sacrificing justice on the shrine of process. Some trials are so long that one wonders whether the process will not collapse under its own weight. I think our greatest challenge over the next several years will be to cope with complexity and prolixity in legal proceedings.

We must find ways to retain a fair process, but in the context of a process that can achieve practical results in a reasonable time and at reasonable expense.

The role of evidence in the criminal justice system

If ways to do this cannot be found, I fear that our legal system will become simply irrelevant for most purposes. The message I bring to you today is not a happy one.

I, for one, am deeply concerned. Criminal Trials are spinning out of control. You bet I am. Long criminal trials are a cancer on our criminal justice system and they pose a threat to its very existence.

You see, ladies and gentlemen, if the criminal justice system does not enjoy the support and respect of those whom it is meant to serve; if criminal trials are seen by the public as little more than interminable games; if the public comes to view the system with distain and contempt, then the system will have lost its reason for being.

And the consequences, I fear, will be serious. Mega trials of that nature are clearly problematic, but I see them as exceptions, and the problems associated with them will almost invariably have to be dealt with on a case-by-case basis.

The long criminal trials about which I am speaking are your standard, ordinary, every-day murder trials, sexual assault trials, robbery trials, drug trials and the like. Those are the trials whose complexion has changed so dramatically over the past twenty years. Those are the trials that bear virtually no resemblance to the trials I engaged in as a defence counsel thirty years ago.

To me they are almost unrecognizable. The problem is a collective one. It belongs to Parliament, it belongs to the judiciary, it belongs to crown attorneys, it belongs to the police, and yes, it belongs as well to the defence bar. It is spinning out of control.

We need to find solutions and we need to act on them now. The time for petty bickering has long since passed. Reform of the Rules of Evidence and Procedure, [2] identified the principal reasons for unduly long trials as case preparation on the eve of trial, and ineffectual pre-hearing conferences.

Regrettably, many judges and counsel have ignored the recommendations. To a large extent those recommendations have been ignored by many judges and counsel.

We are not disposing of cases quickly enough … trials are taking much too long. We must find some ways to make trials more efficient. The committee recommended improved procedures that would have assisted in making trials more focused. Those recommendations have also been ignored by many judges and counsel.Mistrial: An Inside Look at How the Criminal Justice System Works and Sometimes Doesn't [Mark Geragos, Pat Harris] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.

The American legal system changed dramatically when the O. J. Simpson trial became a television-ratings bonanza. Now it’s . Updated March Background. The Australian Human Rights Commission launched its report, Equal before the law: Towards disability justice strategies on 5 February The Report identifies a range of problems that exist in the criminal justice system which result in people with disabilities not enjoying equality before the law.

What is the sequence of events in the criminal justice system? To text description | To a larger version of the chart | Download high resolution version (JPEG - M).

To a larger version of the chart. The flowchart of the events in the criminal justice system (shown in the diagram) updates the original chart prepared by the President's Commission on Law Enforcement and the Administration of.

The Role and Impact of Forensic Evidence in the Criminal Justice Process. POLICE INVESTIGATIONS STUDIES Greenwood P. et al studied detective activities and found that information provided by.

The role of evidence in the criminal justice system

The CPS works in partnership with the police, courts, the Attorney General’s Office, the Home Office, the Ministry of Justice and other agencies throughout the criminal justice system (CJS).

The criminal justice process varies from state to state, and the federal criminal justice system has its own rules, procedures, and terms to describe the stages of the proceedings. Generally speaking, however, the criminal justice process involves the following stages.

The Process of Criminal Justice